Comparison
Trade in at Best Buy, or sell to us?
Best Buy takes phones, iPads, MacBooks and consoles in store, for a gift card. We buy the same devices, for cash. Here's what changes.
By Hamzah AnwarOwner of BuyCellFix and BuyCellTrade
- How you're paid
- Best Buy Trade-In: A Best Buy gift card.
- BuyCellTrade: Cash, or trade-in credit toward a device from the store.
- Where you can spend it
- Best Buy Trade-In: At Best Buy.
- BuyCellTrade: Anywhere: it's money.
- Device condition
- Best Buy Trade-In: A working device.
- BuyCellTrade: Working, cracked or not turning on: each has its price.
- Where
- Best Buy Trade-In: At a participating Best Buy store.
- BuyCellTrade: Laval or Montreal, no appointment, or by mail from anywhere in Quebec.
Terms checked on the official site on November 12, 2026. They can change: check before you decide.
Best Buy is the right call if…
- You're buying at Best Buy anyway and a promotion adds a trade-in bonus.
- A gift card suits you as well as cash.
We're the right call if…
- You want cash.
- Your device is cracked or doesn't work.
- You're not planning to buy anything at Best Buy.
If you're buying at Best Buy during a trade-in promotion, compare their gift card with our price. Otherwise, cash leaves you free.
What we pay today
Our top cash price right now, for a like-new device. Compare it with the other offer, on the same day.
Come compare in person
Two stores, open 7 days a week, no appointment. The evaluation is free, with no obligation.
Laval QC H7V 2V5
- Mon – Wed
- 10 AM – 8 PM
- Thu – Fri
- 10 AM – 9 PM
- Sat – Sun
- 12 PM – 6 PM
Montreal QC H3W 1Y3
Near Snowdon metro
- Mon – Fri
- 11 AM – 9 PM
- Sat – Sun
- 11 AM – 6 PM
Frequently asked questions
Does Best Buy pay cash for an old phone?
No. According to Best Buy's trade-in program page, you get a Best Buy gift card for a working device, at a participating store.
Will Best Buy take a broken PS5 or iPhone?
Best Buy's program talks about working devices. We also buy cracked devices, ones that won't turn on and broken consoles, assessed in store.
Who pays more?
It depends on current promotions. Compare Best Buy's gift card with our price on the same day, keeping in mind a gift card can only be spent in one place.