Skip to content

Sell Your Phone on Marketplace or in a Store?

Facebook Marketplace, Kijiji or a buyback store? What you gain, what you risk and how long it takes. An honest comparison for selling your phone.

By Owner of BuyCellFix and BuyCellTrade

Published November 12, 2026 · 2 min read

Selling your phone in a store: the BuyCellTrade counter

Let's be honest: on Facebook Marketplace or Kijiji, you can often get more money than in a store. A private buyer pays more than a business, which has to test, warranty and resell the device. The real question is whether the gap is worth the time and risk. Here are both sides.

Contents

Marketplace: what you gain

  • The best possible price, if you find the right buyer.
  • You set your price and negotiate.

Marketplace: what it costs

  • Time. Photos, the listing, "still available?" messages, lowball offers, meetups where nobody shows.
  • Risk. Fraudulent payments, fake transfers, counterfeit bills, and meeting a stranger.
  • Comebacks. A buyer who returns saying the battery or screen has a problem.
  • A broken device sells badly. A cracked screen or a phone that won't turn on mostly draws very low offers.

In store: what you gain

  • A price known in advance. Our calculator gives it to you in 30 seconds, and the offer is valid for 7 days.
  • Paid on the spot. A test of a few minutes in front of you, then cash.
  • No haggling, no strangers. Come when it suits you, no appointment.
  • Broken devices have a price. Cracked or not turning on: every model has its offer.

In store: what it costs

  • A lower price than a perfect private sale. That's the price of speed and safety.
  • Photo ID is required for every sale.

How to decide

Compare two numbers on the same day: our price for your model, and the price of sold listings (not just posted ones) on Marketplace. If the gap is small, the store wins: you skip the risk and the time. If the gap is big and the device is perfect, Marketplace can be worth the effort.

For a cracked, old or dead device, the store almost always wins.

Buying another device? Trade-in credit is worth more than our cash offer, which narrows the gap with a private sale.

If you sell on Marketplace

  • Meet the buyer in a public place, in daylight.
  • Don't accept a payment you can't verify on the spot.
  • Remove your iCloud or Google account and reset the device in front of the buyer, after payment.

Frequently asked questions

How much less does a store pay? It depends on the model and its condition. Compare our price with sold listings, on the same day.

Why do you ask for ID? It's required for every used-device sale. It protects everyone against stolen devices.

Where are your stores? In Laval and Montreal, open 7 days a week. Addresses and hours are on our Sell my iPhone page.

Keep reading

Get my price